The Rathskeller

The corned beef was in a nice thick slice that easily falls apart. The sauce was pretty sweet. The sauerkraut didn't have a strong flavor and was rather drippy. The Swiss cheese was nice. The Reuben was a marvelous sandwich, and the best part was the bread, which was grilled to perfection! I loved the free soft pretzels on the table, and the bread to snack on while waiting for the food. I had the spaetzle noodles, not knowing what to expect, and they were delicious, also. The wait staff was friendly, and the atmosphere elegant. I definitely recommend a stop here for their Reuben sandwich.

This place has more atmosphere than any five Reuben establishments I've previously visited. Even though it's in a basement, there's plenty of natural lighting through beautiful windows. You can feel the age of the place just walking across the floorboards. Classical music played as we dined. I felt transported to another place and time. We were seated at a big table for eight, with strangely low chairs. Fresh bread and soft pretzels were set upon a turntable in the center. The pretzels came with a tasty horseradish mustard that opened sinuses I didn't know were closed. Table service was glass, stainless steel, china, and linen napkins. At Aimee's suggestion I had the potato pancake accompaniment, and it was crispy and delicious. The sandwich was just the right size: I still felt full late in the afternoon, but I didn't overstuff myself. The bread was marbled and of perfect crispness, though the bottom slice couldn't stand up long to all the juice. I considered flipping the sandwich onto the peculiarly smaller upper bread slice--and that probably would have worked, since a generous portion of tasty cheese lined it--but I found I didn't really want to set it down! The kraut was good, though I suspect it was the source of much of the juice, and so it might have been better drained. The beef was tender, sliced thin, and unprocessed, providing a wonderful texture. The flavor of the sandwich was utterly distinctive: I'm not sure that it was the best Reuben I've ever had, because I'm not sure I can compare it to the others. Overall it was a delightful experience. Highly recommended.

The Rathskellar Reuben is one worth tasting! For those looking for an authentic Reuben, rest assured the ingredients used at the Rathskeller will not disappoint. The dark cellar atmosphere of the Rathskellar and the German decor create a sensation of being in Germany itself--decorative beer steins, dark wooden bar with European style decor and detail, soft pretzels and spicy mustard, etc. The choice of sides that comes with the Reuben are unique compared with most restaurants in Indianapolis and make for a meal that is an excellent value for the quantity of food received.

The Rathskeller Reuben is one worth tasting! For those looking for an authentic Reuben, rest assured the ingredients used at the Rathskeller will not disappoint. The dark cellar atmosphere of the Rathskeller and the German decor create a sensation of being in Germany itself--decorative beer steins, dark wooden bar with European style decor and detail, soft pretzels and spicy mustard, etc. The choice of sides that comes with the Reuben are unique compared with most restaurants in Indianapolis and make for a meal that is an excellent value for the quantity of food received.